Dorothy Moon

Dorothy Moon

Two weeks ago, the Minnesota State Senate — a legislative chamber controlled by progressive Democrats — approved legislation to give illegal aliens driver’s licenses. It may surprise many that Republicans in Idaho’s State Senate made the same move as Minnesota’s progressive Democrats. Driver’s licenses for illegal aliens erode the rights of U.S. citizens and lawful permanent residents (“Green” card holders) and is another form of corporate welfare that harms the interests of taxpayers.

States issue driver’s licenses under the constitutional authority of the 10th Amendment. However, Congress enacted Real ID in 2005, creating standards for state-issued driver’s licenses, including evidence of lawful status. This new congressional requirement was designed to prevent valid identification from being used by terrorists, agents of foreign adversaries, and those who have entered the country illegally.

The push to give illegal aliens driver’s licenses started in, of course, California. California’s effort — led by pro-open borders groups like La Raza, teachers’ unions, developers, multinational agribusiness corporations and Fortune 500 companies — was meant to ensure that the state’s ever-expanding illegal alien workforce could get access to welfare benefits, enroll in health care programs, and eliminate employers’ cost of transporting illegal alien workers from their homes to job sites.

Since California’s original enactment, 18 and the District of Columbia have enacted laws to allow unauthorized immigrants to obtain driver’s licenses. These states — including Colorado, Connecticut, Delaware, Hawaii, Illinois, Maryland, Massachusetts, Vermont, and Washington — are the most liberal jurisdictions in the Union. They also have some of the lowest-levels of native-born U.S. workforce participation.

That’s right: When you build an economy around cheap, exploitable illegal alien labor, domestic workers fall out of the labor market.

The more damning aspect of giving driver’s licenses to illegal aliens is that it’s a taxpayer giveaway to businesses that want cheap labor but don’t want to pay the accessory costs that come with that cheap labor. Rather than give illegal alien laborers driver’s licenses, employers can provide transportation to and from job sites for these workers.

In these states, driver’s licenses for illegal aliens has also seen a precipitous increase in traffic fatalities and DUIs. It turns out that giving driver’s licenses to foreign nationals with limited familiarity with our laws or language increases the dangers to motorists who obey the law and understand the conventions of our country.

There are a number of politicians in Idaho who like to hector recent transplants to Idaho about what makes Idaho a great place to live, open a small business, and raise a family. These politicians particularly like to remind Californians to “not forget why you left California and why you moved here.”

With some Idaho Republicans moving to give benefits to illegal aliens, maybe the California transplants in Idaho should remind Idaho’s lawmakers of how California ended up being a failed third-world state. California enacted an entire suite of benefits for illegal aliens — starting with driver’s licenses and now including voting rights, instate tuition, hiring preferences based on race and alienage, and language privileges in schools and jobs — at the expense of working Americans. Why would any Idaho Republican want to replicate California’s policies here in Idaho?

Dorothy Moon was elected to serve as the chairwoman of the Idaho Republican Party in July of 2022. Moon served three terms in the Idaho Legislature as State Representative for District 8. Moon’s career in public service has focused on the advancement of individual liberties and reducing the size and scope of government.

Recommended for you

Welcome to the discussion!

The Idaho State Journal invites you to take part in the community conversation. But those who don't play nice may be uninvited.

Comments that are:

  • off topic
  • defamatory
  • libelous
  • obscene
  • racist
  • abusive
  • threatening
  • an invasion of privacy (doxxing)
  • profane (including attempts to misspell profanity in order to get around the profanity filter)

will be deleted. Repeat offenders will lose commenting privileges.

Comments are opinions of the author only, and do not reflect the opinions or views of Idaho State Journal.

(18) comments

Tucson

She doesn't realize this is not a political issue. It's an agricultural issue as well as a safety issue. Those "illegals" are valuable contributors to Idaho's agriculture industry, and it makes sense that they should be required to pass a driving test so they can get to work and operate equipment on the roads.

forgottenman

whatever it's worth, through the initiative process OR voters said nyet to illegal aliens possessing OR driver's licenses only see its past leftist gov trample that, and with complicit Salem leftist lawmakers made it legal to possess driver's licenses for illegal aliens...

wildbill789

Wonder if Dorothy is visiting Aaron von Ellinger in prison? She was such a staunch supporter of the convicted rapist. Republican voters deserve all the shenanigans now going on in the legislature. People, like Moon, are hazardous to your health.

Old Crow

Leftist PC banks in California are going bankrupt and rich commiecrats are losing millions....

It doesn't get any better. Thank you Biden.

Old Crow

I like this woman, the only one in decades besides me to mention La Raza.......THE RACE.....it's funny that nobody ever calls out such obvious racism.

Mike Mathews

Dorthy sure does hate the Californians. Except of course the ton of CA transplants that are flooding western idaho. If there is anyone influencing Idaho politics it's these idiots. Herself, a kansas city native who grew up in the osarks she would like to 'protect' idaho workers. No doubt she's for Idahoans right to organize, have health care and safe working environment.

Old Crow

Look who's stalking.

Old Crow

Primary all the rinos who vote for this treachery.

It's ridiculous that everyone knows the illegals are here and acknowledge that by submitting a bill to give them drivers licenses......yet the local sheriff does absolutely nothing about it. Where are the raids on farms and businesses? Somebody needs to write a bill that allows the seizure of all land, property and bank accounts of the traitors who hire illegals.

red in blue

Why use "cheap, exploitable illegal alien labor" when you can use cheap exploitable Idaho citizen labor? The unionization rate for Idaho in 2022 was the lowest on record. And right wing heroine Sarah Huckster Sanders just signed a bill that gutted child labor laws in Arkansas. Your children's schools aren't being funded, so pull them out of school and put them in the fields, It's the AmeriKKKan way.

Old Crow

Maybe if we put all the little bas-tards to work, they wouldn't have the time to make all the Tik Tok videos. The reason Mormons used to have so many kids was specifically to put them to work on the farms.....now they spoil their kids, coddle them or teach them this sovereign citizen BS that will get them killed. Put the little fockers to work.

Mike Mathews

Yeah..... it's really impressive to hear from a hard working heavy metal failure from Detroit. I'm sure there are a lot of those kind of guys in the fields.

Old Crow

I see that your ba-lls finally dropped.....good for you. I have worked the fields you bonehead....

Picked raspberries and blueberries, moved irrigation pipe, drove truck in the potato harvests

And those workers are mostly mexicans.

Shouldn't you be working at the......YMCA....

Working at the YMCA......in your little sailor outfit

Swabbing di-cks.

Mike Mathews

Yougene confused. Most pipe movers around here were white kids from Poky. Harvest workers were mostly Mexican because the kids went back to school. Yougene didn't move pipe for more than an afternoon and eating raspberries at the egg farm doesn't count as work either. Who ever let yougene into a truck was a bigger idiot than yougene. yougene keep brining up military. The Marine Corps is part of the Navy and if yougene thinks it hurts my feelings that yougene is a bigot well... yougene be yougene. Where did yougene serve our country? Oh yeah....... yougene a coat holder. Kicking your tail hole is easy.

Old Crow

In the navy, where you sucked off Lindsey Graham

In the navy, and you shucked his little clam

In the navy, in the navy.....

So good it deserves to be on replay.

red in blue

Eugene is in his own imaginary military.-"Rahowa my brothers"-Haw Haw

Any day now he will climb on his dragon from "Game of Thrones" and hang us from the wall at "Gilead" from the Handmaid's Tale. HAW HAW

Old Crow

If I only had a dragon. And a 1000 barrels of wildfire. DC would look like the sept. Maybe McConnell will get hit by the bell.

Old Crow

The Trump wall should be long enough.

red in blue

The Trump wall? Trump says Biden hid his wall, you know, at the wall hiding place.