The hype typically outshines the real thing.

Two weeks of intense, sizzling Super Bowl pregame drama? Blowout.

That new mystery flavor of Takis chips they’re going to release on Halloween? Green and gross.

That puppy you pull out your stocking on Christmas morning? Piddles on the couch. Piddles on the pillow. Piddles just about everywhere but on the paper.

But then there’s the Blackfoot softball Broncos. They understand hype is for other people. Drama and hyperbole and overstatement are for the birds, not for the Broncos.

The Blackfoot softball program has had remarkable success over the decades. Broncos’ coach Tammy Sorensen and her staff build a unquestioned powerhouse that has never finished with a losing record under her leadership.

And that’s not hype. That’s the real thing. See the difference?

That reality is predicated on a no-nonsense approach to the game. An approach that minimizes distractions, pushes away the background static and leaves the players at Blackfoot laser-focused on the simple things.

“Blackfoot softball is built on consistency, accountability and a team-first mentality,” Sorensen said. “Our players understand how we practice is how we play, so we emphasize being disciplined in the little things. There’s a standard here — whether it’s effort, attitude or execution — and our girls take pride in living up to that.”

While all that sounds fairly serious and even a little intimidating, it comes from a place of fun. Winning is more fun than that other thing, sure. Regardless of the final tally, the Blackfoot girls can be seen smiling and laughing and having fun — both with each other as well as the so-called opposition.

“When it’s time to compete, we expect focus and toughness, but we also believe chemistry and energy matter,” Sorensen said. “That balance of having fun while still being locked in is a big part of what makes our culture so strong.”

Four games into a 10-game conference season, the Broncos are 10-6 overall and 2-2 against the league. This following a 2025 campaign that saw Blackfoot go 25-6 and sweep through the conference season.

That 2025 team saw a battalion of seniors step across the baseline for the final time when the season ended in May, and the 2026 Broncos are now working with three seniors and nine juniors in a little bit of a roster flip from 12 months ago.

Still, a 25-win season with a fair number of mismatches gives coaches a chance to let players get some infield dust on their varsity cleats.

“Last year gave our upperclassmen a ton of valuable experience, especially in high-pressure situations,” Sorensen said. “They learned what it takes to compete deep into the season — not just physically, but mentally. Managing expectations, handling adversity and staying consistent day in and day out were all big takeaways.”

The Broncos are batting .357 as a team and averaging 10 runs per game. Blackfoot pitchers are also striking out more than one batter per inning through the midway point, setting up an interesting run as they slide into the meat of the conference season.

“Our conference is competitive top to bottom,” Sorensen said. “You have to show up ready to play every day because there aren’t any easy games. Every team is capable of making you pay.”

Junior infielder and Idaho State commit Emma McGuire leads the team with a .552 batting average and has eight of the team’s 20 homers. Teammate Traylee Reed, also a junior, is right behind with a .500 batting average and a team-best 31 RBI.

The pitching duties have fallen fairly evenly between Reed and senior Brianna Reynolds who have 71.2 of the team’s 97.1 innings pitched. The rest belong to junior Rylee Ybarguen and freshman Aniston Evans.

That pretty much sums up how the Broncos go about their business. Players up and down the lineup skipping the hype in favor of the work. Bypassing the noise on their way to the poise.

Serious when it’s serious time, and fun when it’s fun time.

“We’re continuing to learn and grow. We’ve seen some really good things, but we also know there’s another level we can reach,” Sorensen said. “The focus for us is continuing to improve each week, clean up the small details and build momentum as we move deeper into conference play.”

Recommended for you

Welcome to the discussion!

The Idaho State Journal invites you to take part in the community conversation. But those who don't play nice may be uninvited.

Comments that are:

  • off topic
  • defamatory
  • libelous
  • obscene
  • racist
  • abusive
  • threatening
  • an invasion of privacy (doxxing)
  • profane (including attempts to misspell profanity in order to get around the profanity filter)

will be deleted. Repeat offenders will lose commenting privileges.

Comments are opinions of the author only, and do not reflect the opinions or views of Idaho State Journal.