ISU football

Doug Lindley/Idaho State Journal Idaho State’s Jake Pele (44) and Taison Manu (10) take down a Western State-Colorado running back as part of a goal-line stand during Saturday’s game in Holt Arena.

    Because the Idaho State Journal does not publish a Monday newspaper at this point, Monday Morning Quarterback will appear Tuesday morning. Regardless, the premise remains the same.

    The Idaho State Bengals took down a pesky Western State squad Saturday in Holt Arena by a 29-3 margin. In many ways, the defense stole the show as it kept the Mountaineers out of the endzone. The offense, however, left something the be desired. Here are grades for each area of Idaho State’s team in regards to how they performed against Western State.

OFFENSE:

    In the opinion of many, the Bengals should have netted more than 29 points against Western State, a Division II foe. The smaller Mountaineer defense was able to get consistent pressure on ISU quarterback Justin Arias, sacking him twice. Arias, however, fought through it and finished with 436 yards and two touchdowns on 37-of-54 passing. He added a rushing score in the second quarter. Idaho State’s run game struggled, notching just 41 yards on 26 carries (1.6 yards per rush). Three times the Bengals had to settle for field goals instead of touchdowns. On a positive note, they committed just one turnover, a fumble. ISU did not punt until the fourth quarter.

GRADE: C+

DEFENSE:

    Idaho State’s defense had its best performance since last September against Black Hills State. The Bengals did not allow a Mountaineer touchdown, and made an incredible goal-line stand facing first and goal from the four. ISU allowed 113 rushing yards and 154 passing yards, and sacked WSC quarterback Brett Arrivey three times. Redshirt junior linebacker Mitch Beckstead notched nine tackles on the evening, and leads all Bengals with 18 through two games. The team forced just one turnover, a fumble recovery.

GRADE: A-

SPECIAL TEAMS:

    For the second week in a row, ISU’s special teams was the best unit on the field. Redshirt senior placekicker went 3 of 3 on field goal attempts and earned Big Sky Conference Root Sports Special Teams Player of the Week honors for the second week in a row. After going 6 for 12 last year, Garcia is 7 for 7 through two games this season. Idaho State gave up two semi-lengthy runs on kickoff returns, which in the end ultimately yielded no damage for the Bengals

GRADE: A+

COACHING:

    Either the Bengals were surprised by the tenacity and energy with which Western State’s defense played throughout the game, or they weren’t ready for it. Saturday’s contest was the classic “trap” game, with ISU having played a weaker opponent the weekend before, and looking ahead to a matchup with Washington in Seattle the next. Idaho State was surprised out of the gate, but adjusted nicely as the game went on. The defensive staff called a nearly flawless game, and the offensive group did enough for the victory, although more was expected.

GRADE: B-

Recommended for you

Welcome to the discussion!

The Idaho State Journal invites you to take part in the community conversation. But those who don't play nice may be uninvited.

Comments that are:

  • off topic
  • defamatory
  • libelous
  • obscene
  • racist
  • abusive
  • threatening
  • an invasion of privacy (doxxing)
  • profane (including attempts to misspell profanity in order to get around the profanity filter)

will be deleted. Repeat offenders will lose commenting privileges.

Comments are opinions of the author only, and do not reflect the opinions or views of Idaho State Journal.

(1) comment

Ranger11

So Chase, are you making the trip to Seattle?
I have a feeling it is going to be all Garcia for ISU.
Maybe Garcia will get the award for the third week in a row.

Here is a parallel for you, as I said in your column yesterday.
Montana State scored 26 points against Colorado-mesa.
mesa a Rocky Mountain Conference team just as Western state is. An almost perfect rematch spread.

Conclusion?? Either ISU has gotten real good, or Montana State is way over rated. We will know Saturday when Montana State plays North Dakota U.

I really think this washington game is not about win or losing,
nor is it about how bad ISU loses. The score has dropped from 60- to 59. Is that possible? I say no. I say 45.

But if ISU can score 20 points or better they win in the stats.
Maybe even 15, because the spread is 53 points giving ISU only six points. So every point over six for ISU and every point under 59 for Washington makes ISU a winner.

Really, it is going to be wide open mystery. Can ISU put the brakes on Washington--Washington a much older team?

We shall see.