REXBURG, Idaho (AP) — Like many students at Brigham Young University-Idaho, Schada Alkamari felt spiritually drawn to the religious university.
But the Moroccan citizen didn’t enroll to immerse herself in the Mormon faith. She came to BYU-Idaho, which is owned by The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, to reaffirm her own religious beliefs.
Alkamari is a devout Muslim, the only one enrolled at the university.
“I feel like I’m testing my own religion by getting to know the LDS religion,” Alkamari said.
Keeping her faith is important to the 21-year-old. There are no mosques in eastern Idaho, but Alkamari maintains her faith by studying the Quran, fasting during Ramadan and kneeling facedown to pray toward Mecca several times each day.
Alkamari also explores her spirituality through Mormon doctrine. She attends LDS church meetings, takes BYU-Idaho religion classes and has read the Book of Mormon twice.
She disagrees with the central premises of Mormonism, namely the belief that Jesus Christ is a deity. Islamic beliefs teach Christ was an ancient prophet.
“The foundation of the (Mormon) religion just doesn’t convince me,” Alkamari said. “It actually convinces me more to stay with Islam, because I can look at Islam more objectively knowing the LDS faith.”
Still, she finds many parallels between the two religions such as fasting, tithing, chastity, modesty and an emphasis on family.
“I feel so comfortable with Mormons because their principles and values really match my own,” she said.
Alkamari’s opinion of Mormonism is not abnormal among Muslims, said David Peck, a doctor of Middle Eastern studies at BYU-Idaho.
“Many Islamic parents want their children to get a solid, high-quality education at an American university, but in an environment that reinforces values and is respectful and safe,” Peck said. “Church universities are attractive because they emphasize ... going to church and being engaged daily in religion.”
Alkamari’s relationship with Mormons began as a high school exchange student in Virginia.
“(My host family) told me they were LDS and I was very curious, that was why I had come to the United States in the first place,” Alkamari said. “So I got a skirt, I went to church and I loved it.”
She discovered church-owned universities and felt drawn to attend.
But her experience at BYU-Idaho hasn’t been without trials. She said she has endured some religious discrimination and ridicule by students.
“I got some hurtful comments, like ‘you guys bombed the World Trade Centers’ or ‘you guys all look like each other,”’ Alkamari said. “It is hard because when you are (the) odd (person) in a huge society — a negative comment can make you feel like one against everybody.”
Alkamari didn’t feel the incidents warranted reporting to the university, although discrimination of any kind is expressly forbidden by the BYU-Idaho Honor Code.
Dating also is challenging because Mormon doctrine discourages marrying outside the faith. Alkamari feels many Mormon men lose interest once they learn she is Muslim.
Alkamari takes most hardships in stride, fellow student Kristian Workinger said.
“Schada has a great deal of respect for Mormons ... and she is so understanding even when she gets negative feedback,” Workinger said. “She has a good sense of humor and is able to laugh through her trials with a smile on her face.”
Alkamari plans to finish her degree in international studies at BYU-Idaho and eventually work for the United Nations. She plans to continue living in North America.
“I think this experience will allow me to be a better person no matter what I decide to do,” Alkamari said. “Being here is the right path for me.”



(2) comments
In every religion you will find people who are insensitive and intolerant of others. Hope her experience with the Mormons will be mainly positive throughout the rest of her college days in Idaho.
Muslim students have been attending the main BYU campus in Provo since the 1950s, where Mormons can study Arabic and Islam. BYU has a Jerusalem campus on the Mount of Olives that invites Muslims, Jews and Christians who live in Israel to come to the campus and teach their own viewpoints. The current chair of the BYU Provo Religious Studies Department, Camille Fronk Olsen, earned her PhD with a thesis examining the lives of Palestinian Muslim women in Gaza. And BYU sponsors publication of original translations of Arabic language works into English written by Muslims like Al Ghazali "The Incoherence of the Philosophers" etc.
It is ironic that some Protestants attack Mormons for being like Muslims rather than Christians, while the Muslim student in this article emphasizes how Christian Mormons are. What is clear is that the LDS Church really does teach freedom of religion for all people and religious tolerance, that all people are literally spiritual offspring of God the Father, as Paul taught the pagan Greeks in Athens, and that people of all religions benefit to some extent from the redeeming work of Jesus the Christ. Scientific studies by the Pew Charitable Trusts, the University of Pennsylvania, and researchers at Notre Dame and Harvard, all in the last five years, have found that Mormons exceed allother religios groups in their positive acceptance toward people of other religions and denominations, even though many Protestants and religiously unaffiliated Americans express very negative views towards Mormons and Muslims both.
Welcome to the discussion.
Log In